Advertise on the GDN Network
 
 
 
 
GDN Home
News Archives
Members List
Submit Article
GDN Newsletter
GDN Media Kit
Interviews
Reviews
Previews
Screenshots
GDN TV
Patches/Updates
Upcoming Releases
Publishers/Developers
Games List
Review Score Scale
Christophor Rick
The Art of the Press Re...
The Art of the Game Pre...
Shane Dickson
Off to a Good Start...


Razer Tron Video
Yakuza 4 - Saejima
Marvel vs. Capcom 3 - The Hand Hideout
Marvel vs. Capcom 3 - Daily Bugle Gameplay
Dragon Age 2 - Making of Video 1
Rock of Ages -Power Ups
Dungeons Trailer
SSX: Deadly Descents VGA Trailer
X-Men: Destiny Trailer
Mortal Kombat Kratos


GDN Proudly Hosted
on an HWS VPS

Index » Articles Send this page to a friend

Why Grand Theft Auto Was Better Than GTA IV



Posted by Hobgoblin,
  Grand Theft Auto IV
  Articles | FAQ's & Guides | Achievements | Files | Screenshots | Videos | Cheats | Boards |
Amazon Buy Now | GameStop Buy Now | Online Buy Now | UK Buy Now |

You couldn’t buy the kind of savage, razor sharp, contentious hype that surrounded the original Grand Theft Auto game. Just ask Rockstar – they spent millions trying to recreate the buzz with the latest installment in the series. But corporate propaganda could never replace genuine, concerned public outcry, and it seems this advertising fault line now runs through the entire tectonic foundations of the GTA franchise.

Now, I’m not here to bash GTA IV. We at GamersDailyNews already ran a feature about the repellent nature of its hyper-advertising campaign, but at least the game lived up to much of its self-praise (as you can see in the review). The problem is that Grand Theft Auto has lost its way – it’s become something else. Sure, this latest chapter is a remarkable achievement. It’s just not the GTA I fell in love with 10 years ago. It’s become so far removed, in every aspect, that one doesn’t wonder if there’s a minor trade’s descriptions issue at heart.

So what were these major differences that have poisoned the original brand? On a superficial level the first game featured a bird’s eye view of the manic driving escapades, of course. Most gamers will agree that graphics do not make a game (whether quirky and cartoony or photo-realistic), but the choice to view the violence ravaged cities in this retro-tastic way lent the game a vital, toy-like quality that was lost as soon as the third dimension came into play.

Grand Theft Auto was the ultimate big boy’s toy. It was a caustic and sarcastic take on the middle aged man’s obsession with Scalextric or model railways. Those sedate automotive recreations that filled the attic conversions of middle-management types the world over was injected with an hilariously deranged wit; it viciously updated the concept to fall in line with the gradually twisting perceptions of the once-sensitive ‘90’s man’.

The approach of the new millennium saw the male personality veering away from the caring, touchy-feely disposition imposed on him during the last decade. He was once again ready to delight in a bit of harmless chauvinism, and to exert his mannish presence in frivolous venture as he once had. Grand Theft Auto prophetically recognized this impending shift in the Sacred Masculine, and provided precisely the right kind of pseudo-mindless, escapist nonsense the gender so enjoys. The visual style of the original game reflected this attitude perfectly by offering up a contemporary alternative to a sprawling Scalextic track which, if we’re honest, was at its most fun when the small Formula One cars went careening off the track in imagined fiery wreckage.

GTA III and its subsequent spin-offs and sequel seemed to have forgotten – or worse, ignored – this subtle, yet vital characteristic. It went boots first into the 3D realm not because it should, but because it could. And we were all caught up in this revolution in realism, but there was now something missing, despite the fact that on the surface there appeared to be so much more. The ‘big boy’s toy’ quality was stripped away to make room for a shallow, murky, free-roaming 3D world. Sure, it was a great game, but it was a great game for teenagers, the young and the restless – the juvenile middle-ager became a forgotten demographic.

The developer even reflected this dismissal of the grown-up man child by changing its name from DMA Design to Rockstar – an ostentatious, self-congratulatory title intended to alienate all but the ‘coolest’ of gamers.


Rating: 3.1, votes: 77

Comments
Rules
1. No cursing or swear words: Use proper language to express yourself.
2. No flooding or spamming the comment system, abuse will result in a ban.

You may not post comments as a guest. Please register or login to your account.
  #1 Jun 26, 2008 15:24:09

Kobalt
1 Comments

Good article. Can’t say I agree in some parts but still a good article.


  #2 Aug 6, 2010 07:04:59 158 days ago

Braudy
1 Comments
I like this article, but I think you have a touch of First Time Fever. Gamers experience it all the time - they fondly recall the first time they experienced a certain type of game or genre, and that feeling, nay that "high", will never be outmatched. What you described in this article perfectly conveyed the way I felt about Ultima III compared to IV and V, Heroes of Might and Magic III, compared to IV (and ugh, V..). Both of these games introduced me to brand new genres. The good news is some brand new gamers were introduced to open-world RPG’s via GTA III and IV. And so the cycle goes on and on. Regardless of our evolving tastes though, game publishing is simply a business; they had to get fancier and bigger to make money.
 
 
Search the site:

Magic The Gathering: Tactics Set for Free ...
2K Games to Give $1 Million to a Perfect G...
Bionic Commando Rearmed 2 Release Date info
Dragon Age II DLC Announced, Pre-order Bon...
Rift: Planes of Telara Set for March Launch
GamersGate Deals of the Week January 6 2011
Digital Storm - Sandy Bridge Integration
Kick Away the Holiday Pounds with the Kung...
Origin PC Overclocks New Core i7 to 5.0 GH...
CyberPower Debuts Intel-Sandy Bridge Deskt...
Lost in Shadow Review (Wii)
Lylian: Episode 1- Paranoid Fr...
Raskulls Review (XBLA)
A World of Keflings Review (XBLA)
A Space Shooter for Two Bucks ...
Dead Rising 2: Case West Revie...
Soulcaster 2 Review (XBL Indie...
Heroes of Newerth Strategy Gui...
Back to the Future Episode 1: ...
Heroes of Newerth Strategy Gui...

Affiliations
& Friends



IVDC 2010 Logo
Italian Videogame Developers Conference

Donate Games Logo
IMGA logo
 
Advertise | Submit News | Contact | Pages | Blogs | Downloads | Video | Privacy Policy | About Us | GDN Staff | GDN Review Scale
News & Articles RSS | News RSS | Article RSS | Video RSS | Reviews RSS
 
 
|